Beware of "Bait" or "Phantom" Listings When Buying a Watch

The world of pre-owned luxury watches is exciting, whether you’re looking for a Rolex or a hot Patek Philippe. However, while the thrill of finding a beautiful timepiece at a great price is undeniable, there are hidden risks in this market. One of the most common and dangerous pitfalls is the “bait” or “phantom” listings.

In this post, we’ll dive into what these listings are, why they work, and how you can avoid them to ensure a smooth and secure pre-owned luxury watch purchase.

What Are "Bait" or "Phantom" Listings?

“Bait” or “phantom” listings are fraudulent ads that entice buyers with seemingly great deals on watches that either don’t exist or aren’t actually for sale. These listings often feature limited or poor-quality photos, paired with prices below market value.

There are two main types of these scams:

The Temporarily Unavailable Watch: In this classic bait-and-switch tactic, a seller lists an attractive watch at a great price. However, when you inquire, the watch has “just been sold.” Conveniently, the seller offers you another, less desirable or more expensive watch instead. The original watch was never available—it was just bait.
The Sourcing Delay: In this scenario, the seller lists a watch they don’t actually have in stock. After you place your order, they claim they’ll “source” the watch for you. This can lead to long delays, and in some cases, the watch may not be what you expected when it arrives.

In the example above you will find photos of a real watch listing with all its content, including displaying partial date of purchase and abilities to counts the links on the Bracelet. So there is no doubt this the timepiece you will receive.

Previous slide

Next slide

In the example above you will find photos of a bait listing with no photo of all its content, not displaying date of purchase and abilities to counts the links on the Bracelet. So there is no way to confirm this the timepiece you will receive.

Why Do These Scams Work?

These scams prey on the excitement and urgency that often come with buying luxury watches. When buyers think they’ve found a rare model at an unbeatable price, emotions can cloud judgment. Scammers exploit this by offering limited-time deals or claiming that multiple buyers are interested.

Additionally, the global nature of the luxury watch market—where buyers and sellers often conduct business online or across borders—makes it easier for unscrupulous dealers to create fake listings. The physical distance between buyer and seller makes verifying the watch’s existence difficult.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

If you’re in the market for a pre-owned luxury watch, watch out for these warning signs that could indicate a bait or phantom listing:

Below-Market Prices: While deals exist, if a watch is priced significantly below market value, it’s a red flag. Always research the average price for the model you’re interested in before making a purchase.
Limited or Poor-Quality Photos: Scammers often use stock images or blurry photos to hide the fact that they don’t actually have the watch. Legitimate sellers usually provide high-quality images of the watch from multiple angles, including the serial number and warranty card.
Urgency and Pressure: Scammers often create a sense of urgency, claiming that the watch is in high demand or that multiple buyers are interested. This tactic is designed to pressure you into making a quick decision without asking too many questions.
Lack of Transparency: A reputable seller will provide detailed information about the watch, including its condition, history, and any documentation that comes with it. If a seller is vague or unwilling to share this information on the listing, it’s a bad sign

How to Protect Yourself When Buying a Pre-Owned Luxury Watch

To avoid falling victim to bait or phantom listings, follow these tips:

Research Thoroughly: Before making a purchase, research the watch model, its typical market price, and its condition. Familiarize yourself with reputable pre-owned luxury watch dealers and marketplaces. Check reviews and testimonials from other buyers.
Only Use Trusted dealers: Buy from a well-established watch dealer. These sites often provide authentication guarantees, return policies, and good reviews.
Stay Skeptical: If something feels off, trust your instincts. There’s no harm in walking away from a deal if you’re not 100% confident about its legitimacy.

Conclusion

The thrill of finding a pre-owned luxury watch at a great price is exciting, but the risks associated with bait and phantom listings are very real. By being cautious, doing your homework, and using trusted platforms, you can confidently navigate the market and avoid falling into unwanted complications.

In today’s digital age, there’s no reason for sellers to provide poor-quality listings or photos. At Capturing Watches, we prioritize transparency by providing detailed images of every watch and its contents with all of our E-commerce Watch Photography. This helps ensure you know exactly what you’re getting.

Stay savvy, do your due diligence, and enjoy the hunt for your next luxury timepiece. Happy watch hunting!